By Nicole Gullan, Associate Director, Arbtech
The new biodiversity net gain (BNG) exemption for smaller sites was intended to take pressure off development, particularly smaller residential schemes where the cost of delivering biodiversity improvements could make a project unviable.
Since 6 August, when the new 0.2-hectare threshold came into effect, we have seen a reduction of less than 10% in applications requiring BNG. That is considerably lower than the Government’s estimate that around half of residential developments could fall outside the mandatory requirements.
Our experience is only a snapshot of the market, rather than a national measure, but it raises a question about how much difference the change will make in practice.
We are already seeing developers reconsidering the timing of applications, looking again at site boundaries and, in some cases, making decisions based on whether they can avoid the cost of off-site biodiversity units. The exemption is influencing decisions, although it is not as straightforward as some might expect.
One leisure operator, for example, has paused plans to renovate an existing sports club and intends to submit a fresh application now the exemption is available. We have also seen a proposed new home abandoned by one developer because of the cost of off-site biodiversity units, before another developer bought the scheme with the new exemption in mind. In that case, the change in the rules has had a direct bearing on the scheme’s viability.
But qualifying for the exemption is not simply a matter of getting below 0.2 hectares.
The site must also avoid impacting on-site priority habitat. Hedgerows can be important here, alongside deciduous woodland. A developer may have a site below the threshold and still find that BNG applies because of the habitat present.
There is also a distinction that needs to be understood from the outset: being exempt from BNG does not mean being exempt from ecological assessment.
The baseline requirement for a Preliminary Ecological Appraisal (PEA) has not changed. Developers still need to understand what is on their site and councils may ask for an exemption statement prepared by a qualified ecologist, sometimes supported by a baseline biodiversity metric. Other surveys may be needed depending on the site and the proposed works.
That work is not a formality to be dealt with at the end of the planning process. If a developer assumes an exemption applies and discovers late in the day that it does not, there may be little time to accommodate the BNG requirement without redesigning the scheme or incurring additional costs.
We have seen this uncertainty play out with a proposal for two dwellings where the developer has tightened the red-line boundary to bring the site below 0.2 hectares. The presence of a canal raises a further question about whether the exemption applies. The position is not yet settled and the outcome will depend on the assessment of the habitat and the planning authority’s approach.
It is a useful example of why red-line boundaries need careful consideration. Developers are looking at whether they can reduce the area within the application boundary and that may be a sensible option where it accurately reflects the land needed for the development. But the boundary still needs to include the areas affected by the proposals. It cannot simply be drawn more tightly to avoid BNG if the development’s actual footprint and impacts extend beyond it.
Some of the rules may appear self-explanatory, but their application can be more complicated. We are seeing councils take different approaches to exemption evidence and developers should not assume that a small site or a revised boundary will automatically settle the matter.
The wider picture is still evolving. A possible further exemption for certain brownfield residential developments remains subject to the Government’s consultation process, so developers should not treat it as an established route at this stage. Changes to the wider BNG framework are also in prospect, while mandatory BNG for nationally significant infrastructure projects (NSIPs) is due to come into effect on 2 November 2026.
The off-site market remains another important consideration. For some schemes, the cost of buying biodiversity units can have a material impact on viability. Watercourse units, in particular, can be expensive, although prices vary and individual schemes will need to be assessed on their own circumstances. Where a project is close to the threshold of viability, the difference between being exempt and having to deliver BNG can be decisive.
The intention behind the exemption is understandable. Smaller developments can face costs and complexity that are difficult to absorb, mostly where margins are tight. But the changes have not removed the need for sound ecological advice or made every exemption straightforward to apply.
For developers, the best course is to establish the ecological position early, check whether the exemption genuinely applies and speak to an ecologist before committing to a planning strategy. That may mean a scheme still needs BNG, despite falling below 0.2 hectares. It is better to establish that at the outset than to discover it when an application is already under way.
We believe the Government now needs to give the market greater clarity on the remaining changes and how they will work in practice. Once that is done, some stability would be welcome. Developers and their advisers need to be able to make decisions with confidence, rather than repeatedly revisiting the same questions as the rules evolve.















